Tuesday, December 4, 2007

Reputation

In reality, the business of writing about video games is a somewhat small community. Certainly there are a ton of people casually writing either as industry insiders or analysts or critics at all corners of the web, but when it comes down to the number of really credible writers out there with consistent content available in significant outlets you're probably talking about a pretty small number. Truth is, I really don't count myself among their occasionally august company yet, though I'm trying to sneak my way through the backdoor. Though, I am also keenly aware that the desire to be part of the gaming-media is perhaps the strongest leverage available to the people who work in the actual gaming industry.

I think it was Jeff Green who really set me straight on the distinction that needs to be drawn there. People in the gaming media do not work in the gaming industry. And, suddenly now I see everywhere I look people writing about the industry in an inclusive manner, as though we're all one big happy family. I'm sure part of that is a need for validation, but also, I think there's this sense that if you want to get into writing about games you've got to make people like you. Certainly that's what the people who represent developers and publishers would like.

And, that's ok. It's their job to protect their clients and create a favorable media environment.

But, that's not the job of the gaming media. It's not what I believe is either interesting or meaningful, to be a necessary friend of a marketing plan. Sure, it helps you make contacts, which helps you be able to pitch better stories, which helps open the doors with editors, which helps you become a name, but entering through that door with half your soul already sold isn't really worth the time, is it? Besides, I think most good editors see right through those guys.

I wonder if in my writings for Gamerswithjobs and Escapist so far, where I have been abrupt and direct in my criticisms of the past, if I have a bad reputation or a reputation at all. I know from working on some recent stories that the people I'm calling sometimes already know who I am, and of course they are my best friends on the phone because that's their job and they're good at it, but I wonder when I hear them say, "oh yes, I've read some of your work before" if that's going to work to my advantage or disadvantage. This appears to be a media environment where being open, honest and, when necessary, brutal are not very well appreciated.

So, I see why a lot of writers and publications would be at least tempted to play-ball.

But, what I think a lot of these folks forget is that while publications can't survive without the revenue of their advertisers, the advertisers can't survive without the publications to put their ads in. We writers shouldn't be feeling like someone's done us a favor by telling us part of the truth, or giving us access to a game developer so they can talk about their game. We're the ones doing the service for them, and our questions and investigations are not some inconvenience to be suffered and discarded but part of the process.

So, despite the occasional obstacles it may put in my path, I hope that my reputation is that of someone who isn't likely to play the game. I think I'll take a little pride when I hear someone on the other end of the line feel a little uncertain or uncomfortable when we speak, not because I'm unpredictable but because of the exact opposite. That is the kind of identity I hope to build.

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

Yes. Yes that is your reputation. It's certainly the GWJ reputation.